Citric Acid and Malic Acid: Comparing Organic Acid Options

Citric Acid and Malic Acid: Comparing Organic Acid Options

Citric acid and malic acid are two types of organic acids commonly found in the food industry. These acids are widely used as food additives, flavoring agents, and as an ingredient in several products to maintain their pH level. While both have a sour taste, there are significant differences between citric and malic acid regarding their physical and chemical properties, production, health benefits, and applications in the food industry. This article aims to compare and contrast the two acids in-depth and figure out which one is better suited for various applications.

What are Citric Acid and Malic Acid?

Citric acid is a weak organic acid with the molecular formula C6H8O7. It is naturally found in citrus fruits, such as lemons and limes, and some berries. Citric acid is also commonly produced through fermentation using various microorganisms, including the fungus Aspergillus niger. On the other hand, malic acid is an organic dicarboxylic acid with the molecular formula C4H6O5, which is predominantly found in fruits such as apples, pears, and grapes. Malic acid is also synthesized from fumaric acid or maleic acid through a chemical process known as hydration.

Citric acid and malic acid are commonly used in the food industry as flavor enhancers and preservatives. Citric acid is often added to soft drinks, candies, and baked goods to give them a tart, acidic taste. It is also used as a natural preservative to prevent spoilage and extend the shelf life of food products. Similarly, malic acid is used in the production of fruit-flavored beverages, candies, and chewing gum to provide a sour taste. It is also used as a preservative in some food products, such as canned fruits and vegetables.

Aside from their use in the food industry, citric acid and malic acid have various other applications. Citric acid is commonly used in cleaning products, such as detergents and dishwashing liquids, due to its ability to remove mineral deposits and stains. It is also used in the pharmaceutical industry as an excipient, which is a substance added to a medication to improve its taste or texture. Malic acid, on the other hand, is used in the production of cosmetics and personal care products, such as shampoos and skin creams, due to its ability to improve the texture and stability of these products.

Production of Citric and Malic Acid

Citric acid can be obtained through three primary processes – extraction from natural sources, chemical synthesis, and microbial fermentation. It is commercially produced through a submerged fermentation process using various microorganisms, mainly Aspergillus niger. Aspergillus niger produces a high yield of citric acid using molasses or corn syrup as a substrate. On the other hand, malic acid is synthesized by hydrating fumaric acid or by the auto-oxidation of butane-1,4-diol. The chemical process involves the reaction of maleic anhydride with an alcohol in a condensation reaction to obtain a cyclic ester, and the final product is then hydrolyzed to produce malic acid.

Citric acid is widely used in the food and beverage industry as a flavor enhancer, preservative, and acidulant. It is also used in the pharmaceutical industry as an excipient in the formulation of tablets and capsules. Additionally, citric acid is used in the cosmetic industry as a pH adjuster and chelating agent.

Malic acid is commonly used in the food industry as a flavor enhancer, acidulant, and preservative. It is also used in the production of wine to enhance the flavor and balance the acidity. In the cosmetic industry, malic acid is used as an exfoliant and skin conditioner. Furthermore, malic acid is used in the pharmaceutical industry as an excipient in the formulation of tablets and capsules.

Physical and Chemical Properties of Citric and Malic Acid

Citric acid is a colorless, translucent, crystalline powder with a strong acidity, while malic acid appears as a white crystalline powder with an acidic taste and is highly soluble in water. Citric acid is a weak acid with a pH range of 2.2-2.5, while malic acid is slightly stronger with a pH range of 3.3-3.5. The molecular weight of citric acid is 192.12 g/mol, and that of malic acid is 134.08 g/mol.

Citric acid is commonly found in citrus fruits such as lemons, limes, and oranges, while malic acid is found in apples, pears, and other fruits. Both acids are widely used in the food industry as flavor enhancers, preservatives, and acidifiers. Citric acid is also used in the production of cleaning agents, cosmetics, and pharmaceuticals, while malic acid is used in the production of wines and other beverages.

While both citric and malic acid have similar chemical properties, they have different effects on the human body. Citric acid can increase the absorption of aluminum in the body, which has been linked to Alzheimer's disease, while malic acid has been shown to improve muscle performance and reduce fatigue. Therefore, malic acid is often used as a supplement by athletes and people with chronic fatigue syndrome.

The Role of Citric and Malic Acid in Food Preservation

Citric and malic acid are commonly used in food preservation to maintain the pH of food products and prevent the growth of spoilage microorganisms. In canned foods, citric acid is used to prevent discoloration, while malic acid is used to enhance natural fruit flavors. Both acids are also used as acidity regulators in sodas, fruit juices, jams, and jellies to provide tartness and a sour taste.

Additionally, citric and malic acid have been found to have antioxidant properties, which can help to prevent the oxidation of fats and oils in food products. This is particularly important in products that have a long shelf life, such as packaged snacks and baked goods. The use of these acids in food preservation has been shown to extend the shelf life of products and reduce the need for artificial preservatives, making them a popular choice among food manufacturers and consumers alike.

Health Benefits of Citric and Malic Acid

Both citric and malic acid have numerous health benefits when consumed in moderate amounts. Citric acid is known to boost metabolism, promote digestion, and enhance the body's absorption of iron. It is also an antioxidant that can neutralize free radicals, which cause oxidative stress and damage cells. Malic acid, on the other hand, is known to promote liver health, enhance physical stamina, and prevent muscle fatigue. It is also a natural pain reliever and can reduce the symptoms of fibromyalgia.

In addition to their individual health benefits, citric and malic acid also work together to improve overall health. When consumed together, they can help regulate blood sugar levels, reduce inflammation, and improve cardiovascular health. Citric acid can also enhance the absorption of malic acid, allowing for greater benefits to be obtained from both acids. It is important to note that while citric and malic acid have many health benefits, consuming too much of either acid can lead to negative side effects such as stomach upset and tooth enamel erosion. It is recommended to consume these acids in moderation as part of a balanced diet.

Differences between the Taste and Flavor Profile of Citric and Malic Acid

The taste and flavor profile of citric and malic acid differ significantly. Citric acid has a tart, tangy flavor with a strong sour taste that is often described as lemon-like. In contrast, malic acid has a milder sour taste with a hint of sweetness, similar to the sourness of green apples. Therefore, malic acid is more commonly used to enhance fruit flavors in food, while citric acid is used in products where a strong sour taste is required.

It is important to note that citric acid is naturally found in citrus fruits such as lemons, limes, and oranges, while malic acid is found in fruits such as apples, pears, and grapes. Additionally, citric acid is commonly used as a preservative in food and beverages, while malic acid is used in the production of wine to balance the sweetness and acidity of the grapes. Understanding the differences between these two acids can help in creating the desired taste and flavor profile in various food and beverage products.

Application of Citric and Malic Acid in the Food Industry

Citric and malic acid are widely used as food additives in various products, including soft drinks, fruit juices, candies, and bakery products. Citric acid is used as a natural preservative in canned fruits and vegetables, while malic acid is commonly used in the production of wine, cider, and fruit-based soft drinks.

In addition to their use as food additives, citric and malic acid also have other applications in the food industry. Citric acid is used as a flavor enhancer in many processed foods, such as sauces, dressings, and marinades. It is also used in the production of cheese, where it helps to control the acidity and flavor of the cheese. Malic acid, on the other hand, is used in the production of sour candies, such as sour gummies and sour patch kids. It provides the sour taste that is characteristic of these candies.

Another important application of citric and malic acid is in the production of sports drinks and energy drinks. These drinks often contain electrolytes, such as sodium and potassium, which help to replenish the body's fluids and minerals after exercise. Citric and malic acid are added to these drinks to provide a tart, refreshing taste that helps to mask the salty flavor of the electrolytes.

Citric vs Malic Acid: Which is Better for Cooking?

When it comes to cooking, both citric and malic acid have their unique properties. Citric acid is commonly used in cooking to provide a sour taste to dishes, such as marinades, dressings, and sauces. It is also commonly used in desserts, such as lemon curd and sorbets. On the other hand, malic acid is used to enhance the natural flavor of fruits and is commonly used in the production of apple pies and ciders. It can also be used as a substitute for citric acid in some recipes.

It is important to note that citric acid is more acidic than malic acid, with a pH level of 2.2 compared to malic acid's pH level of 3.4. This means that citric acid is better suited for recipes that require a strong acidic flavor, while malic acid is better suited for recipes that require a milder, fruitier flavor. Additionally, citric acid is more soluble in water than malic acid, which makes it easier to incorporate into recipes that require a liquid base. However, malic acid is more stable at high temperatures, making it a better choice for recipes that require baking or cooking at high temperatures.

Medical uses of Citric and Malic Acid

Both citric and malic acid have medical applications. Citric acid is used as a chelating agent to remove heavy metals from the bloodstream in conditions such as lead poisoning. It is also used as a urinary alkalinizer to prevent the formation of kidney stones. Malic acid is used as a natural pain reliever and is often used to reduce the symptoms of fibromyalgia.

In addition to these uses, citric acid is also used in the production of certain medications, such as effervescent tablets and liquid medications. It is also used in the food industry as a preservative and flavor enhancer. Malic acid is commonly found in many fruits and vegetables, and is often used as a natural food additive to enhance flavor and texture. It is also used in the production of certain cosmetics and skin care products due to its exfoliating properties.

Citric vs Malic Acid: Which is More Acidic?

Citric acid is a weak acid with a pH of 2.2-2.5, while malic acid is slightly stronger, with a pH of 3.3-3.5. Therefore, malic acid is more acidic than citric acid.

Despite malic acid being more acidic than citric acid, both acids are commonly used in the food industry. Citric acid is often used as a preservative and flavor enhancer in beverages, candies, and baked goods. Malic acid, on the other hand, is commonly found in fruits such as apples and grapes, and is used as a flavoring agent in sour candies and some carbonated beverages.

While both acids have their uses, they can also have negative effects on dental health. Citric acid, in particular, can erode tooth enamel and lead to tooth decay if consumed in excess. It is important to consume acidic foods and beverages in moderation and to practice good oral hygiene to prevent dental problems.

Citric vs Malic Acid: Which is More Versatile?

Both citric and malic acid have unique properties that make them versatile in different applications. Citric acid's strong sour taste makes it more versatile in products where a strong acidic taste is required. Malic acid's mild, fruity flavor, on the other hand, is more versatile in enhancing the natural flavors of fruits and berries. Therefore, the choice between citric and malic acid depends on the desired taste and flavor profile of the product.

It's worth noting that citric acid is also commonly used as a preservative due to its ability to inhibit the growth of bacteria and mold. This makes it a popular choice in the food industry for products that require a longer shelf life. Malic acid, on the other hand, is often used in the cosmetic industry for its exfoliating properties. It helps to remove dead skin cells and promote a brighter, more even complexion.

The Chemistry behind the Sour Taste in Citrus Fruits vs Apples

The sour taste in citrus fruits is due to the presence of citric acid, while the sour taste in apples is due to the presence of malic acid. Both acids stimulate the taste buds on the tongue, triggering an acidic taste sensation. However, the chemical structures of the two acids differ, resulting in a difference in the strength and quality of the sour taste. Citric acid has a stronger sour taste, while malic acid has a milder, fruitier sour taste.

Another difference between the sour taste in citrus fruits and apples is the way in which the acids are distributed within the fruit. Citrus fruits have a higher concentration of citric acid in the juice, while apples have a higher concentration of malic acid in the flesh. This is why biting into a lemon or lime can be more intense than biting into an apple.

Interestingly, the sour taste in both citrus fruits and apples can be altered by cooking or processing. Heating citrus fruits can cause the citric acid to break down, resulting in a less sour taste. Similarly, cooking apples can cause the malic acid to break down, resulting in a sweeter taste. This is why lemon juice can be used to add a sour taste to dishes, while apple sauce can be used to add sweetness.

How to Extract Citric and Malic Acid from Natural Sources

Citric acid can be extracted from natural sources such as lemon and lime juice, as well as grapefruit, oranges, and other citrus fruits. The acid is extracted by squeezing the fruit juice, which is then treated with calcium hydroxide to form calcium citrate. Citric acid is then extracted from calcium citrate by treating it with sulfuric acid, which releases citric acid. Malic acid can be extracted by crushing and pressing fruits such as apples, which contain high levels of the acid, and then filtering the juice to remove any solid materials. The malic acid can be concentrated by evaporation and then purified using ion exchange resins.

Citric vs Malic Acid: Pros & Cons

Citric acid has a stronger sour taste and is more commonly used as a preservative in canned foods and soft drinks. It is also commonly used to provide a sour taste to dishes in cooking. However, it may not be suitable for enhancing natural fruit flavors. Malic acid, on the other hand, has a milder sour taste and is commonly used to enhance the natural flavors of fruits and berries. It is also used in the production of apple cider and pies. However, it may not be suitable for products that require a strong acidic taste.

Overall, both citric and malic acid have their unique properties, and choosing the right acid for a particular application depends on the desired taste and flavor profile of the product. By examining the production process, physical and chemical properties, health benefits, and applications in the food industry, we can compare and contrast citric and malic acid and determine which acid is best suited for different uses.


© Brave in Bloom, 2023